Strategic Bitcoin Reserve Sparks Heated U.S. Debate

٢٤ يناير ٢٠٢٥ BACK TO NEWS

Debate on U.S. Strategic Bitcoin Reserve grows, exploring legal, regulatory, and financial implications - IcoHolder.

The conversation around the establishment of a Strategic Bitcoin Reserve (SBR) in the United States is intensifying, drawing in legal, political, and financial experts. Prominent attorney and XRP advocate John E. Deaton recently outlined key considerations for creating such a reserve, emphasizing that its success hinges on robust legal and regulatory frameworks. His comments add depth to a discussion that has already seen input from lawmakers, analysts, and industry leaders.

Deaton clarified the various interpretations of an SBR. For some, it could involve holding onto seized Bitcoin and other digital currencies in a secure government-controlled vault rather than selling them. This approach, he noted, could be implemented through an executive order issued by the president. “If you want to call that a Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, then I am sure that we will get one,” Deaton remarked. However, he explained that a scenario where the government actively purchases Bitcoin would require legislative backing. He highlighted Senator Cynthia Lummis' proposed bill as a possible foundation for such a strategy.

Lummis, a staunch advocate for cryptocurrency regulation, has taken on a pivotal role as chair of the Senate’s Digital Assets Subcommittee, sparking optimism among experts, including Binance founder Changpeng Zhao (CZ), for the realization of an SBR.

Trump’s Executive Order and the Stockpile Debate
Former President Donald Trump recently signed an executive order establishing a working group to explore the creation of a national digital asset stockpile. Notably, the order used the term “stockpile” rather than “reserve.” Bloomberg analyst James Seyffart highlighted the distinction, explaining that “stockpile” implies retaining assets seized through law enforcement, whereas “reserve” suggests deliberate market purchases.

Trump’s executive order tasks the working group with drafting guidelines for managing these digital assets. It remains unclear whether all government-held assets, currently valued at over $20 billion according to Arkham Intelligence, will be retained. The portfolio includes 198,109 Bitcoin, alongside smaller amounts of Ethereum, stablecoins, and other tokens.

Controversy Among Crypto Stakeholders
The potential creation of a Bitcoin-centric reserve has also sparked division within the cryptocurrency community. Pierre Rochard, Vice President of Research at Riot Platforms, accused Ripple Labs of opposing a Bitcoin-focused SBR to advance its own currency, XRP. Ripple’s leadership has dismissed these claims, calling them unfounded.

Meanwhile, analysts continue to weigh in on the implications of the executive order. Alex Thorn pointed out that the guidelines would likely recommend retaining only select digital assets. “It’s a logical and measured approach,” agreed James Seyffart, reflecting the measured tone of the working group’s mission.

The Road Ahead for a Strategic Bitcoin Reserve
As the debate over a Strategic Bitcoin Reserve evolves, the focus remains on aligning policy with the rapidly changing digital asset landscape. Whether through executive orders or new legislation, the question of how—and if—the U.S. government will formalize its relationship with Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies is poised to remain a hot topic in the months ahead.